Sunday, February 28, 2010
DR - II
I was halfway into that particular question algorithm when the patient’s daughter quietly interrupted. She handed me a piece of paper with a biopsy report dated seven days prior stating that her father had a sinonasal undifferentiated carcinoma, a malignancy with an extremely poor prognosis even with optimal surgical and adjuvant treatment. I looked at the report and then glanced at the patient, who continued to talk happily without a care in the world. I asked him (through the translator) what he knew about his condition, and he stated that he knew he had a biopsy, but nothing more.
This was a relatively alien situation to me, as aside from PCM sessions with standardized patients, I’ve never had to tell anyone that they had a malignancy with an extremely poor prognosis. I decided to let the attending deliver the news and conducted a thorough physical. Once I left the room, I took the translator and the patient’s daughter with me to present the patient. We explained the seriousness of her father's condition and the necessary therapeutic options. The patient’s daughter was insistent that her father not be told about his diagnosis. As visitors to the country, we agreed, but wrote her a letter of referral to the country’s only cancer center should she change her mind. After several awkward moments dictating said letter to an exceedingly patient Peace Corps volunteer, she thanked us before we went to examine her father further.
My time at Loyola taught me, among other things, the importance of patient autonomy and its place as a cornerstone of American medical ethics. We did not impose this particular value in this case, and did not feel as if we'd committed a grave ethical misstep. Indeed, the same scenario might have played out exactly as described in my family. It would take more than a blog entry to fully discuss the differential value of patient autonomy in Santiago versus Chicago. Cultural sensitivity notwithstanding, I still felt a pang of guilt when, upon leaving, the patient asked if his nasal stuffiness and facial pressure would ever improve. I told him that the medications we provided would take care of his symptoms, all the while glancing at his daughter to see if she'd change her mind. She didn't. They left and I wished them well.
Ryan JE Salvador, MSIV
Santiago, DR
DR - I
This enthusiasm for medical care extended to the surgeries; a patient walking from the preoperative area to the operating rooms was always accompanied by a quick prayer, a pep talk and applause. It was in rather sharp contrast to the somber atmosphere that accompanies the American patients’ journey to the ORs at home.
On a side note, I rue the day I took French as opposed to Spanish in high school. Even though it helps slightly with understanding certain culinary terms, no one at LUMC has ever asked for a French translator.
I was on call with another non-Spanish fluent student on a night when the patient dorms were full of patients who had thyroidectomies. Prior to our shift, we'd attempted to learn choice Spanish sentences and phrases ("Are you in pain? Do you have tingling around your mouth and fingertips? Are you nauseous? May we see your wound?"). We asked these questions upon checking our patients every two hours, all the while hoping that the answer would be "No," as anything other than that would necessitate further questions in broken Spanglish and probably a change in management. Through sheer luck, the answer was always "No." It was a good night.
Ryan JE Salvador, MSIV
Santiago, DR
Friday, February 26, 2010
Paucity of Language?
Such was the case while we were in the DR, but fortunately for us we had the assistance of several Peace Corps volunteers (PCVs) to aid in translation. For clinic, interviews rode the slow train from English to Spanish and back, which made things difficult when seeing upwards of 80 patients daily. In an effort to improve efficiency, I tried to learn the basic introduction of name and role and thus spare the interpreter from doing everything. To my credit I have several years of French under my belt, plus a decent understanding of Latin root pronunciation, and so I thought I could muscle my way through the introduction. Every patient, without exception, smiled politely at my attempt and then turned to the interpreter to find out what I had just said. On woman presenting with an apparently painful thyroid nodule just started laughing and shaking her head, before seeking the translator's help. In between patients one of the PCVs told me not to take it personally, the people were just not expecting me to speak Spanish, so they would tune it out regardless even if I had spoken flawless Dominican Spanish. So with that in the back of my mind, I foraged ahead focusing on the language that I knew better than Spanish: eye contact, “interested” eyebrows, positive vocal inflection and a forward lean. For the most part it worked well though I did run into a little trouble on the last day of clinic.
In the mild chaos that was the last day we were attempting to both close shop and pack-up supplies while finishing up clinic and operations. In addition to sorting and packing I was also pinch-hitting as the only student taking care of the last few patients coming through clinic. I was a little short on sleep at the time and was keeping my spirits buoyed by humming to myself. In the midst of things I was asked to flush wax out an elderly woman's ears so that she could get a hearing test. With the same PCV who had been helping my Spanish skills, I went to work irrigating entrenched wax plugs out of her ears. In similar situations in the US, I make light of my difficulties by giving the patient status updates in a rather sing-song fashion thereby breaking some of the tension in the room. However, as I was doing this I realized that this poor woman had no idea what I was saying and could only imagine what she was thinking about this odd young man alternating serenading and blasting warm water into her ear. I asked the PCV, Sarah, to feel free to translate in whatever fashion she felt was best. Thankfully she chose calm matter-of-fact prose to more lyrical reassurances. I guess if I do something like this again in the future I will try harder to learn the primary language as opposed to just letting my body language do the talking.
Christopher Janowak MSIV
Santiago, DR
Thursday, February 25, 2010
No Habla Espanol
The peace corps translators were very capable, intelligent people. As one can read in previous posts, they all had amazing projects that were doing much more for these communities than our 1 week surgical trip. They had a solid command of the language and were absolutely vital throughout the entire trip. Yet, one problem I found as our the days wore-on was that the translators were being forced to play doctor. The peace corps translators were doing what we had been learning these last four years, except without any medical training. They were listening to the patient's story, ignoring those parts deemed to be insignificant and then picking out the salient details to communicate to us. And, while I did have faith in the peace corps volunteers' abilities to pick up on the basics of obstructive sleep apnea or recurrent tonsilitis, I did not expect them to be functioning on the level of nurses or physicians. Yet, this is the position many were forced into during the long days in clinic. It is important to note that rarely, if ever, during our trip was this sort of analytical translation ever detrimental to patient care. Still, I believe it was definitely less than ideal to have the translators doing as much doctoring as the medical students. Unfortunately, the time constraints and absent Spanish skills of students like me necessitated this approach. The question then is how would we be able to avoid this in the future? The simple solution is we would need more medical students who were fluent in Spanish. Only then would the patients get straight from the doctor medical advice.
The sad fact is that there are many medical students like me who lack basic foreign language skills. I would venture to guess that far less than a majority of medical students in the United States have conversational fluency in a non-English language. It is something that I regret every day when on-service at Loyola, not being able to converse with the multitude of Spanish speaking patients. I can get by with my "Te duele?" or "Respire profundo," but I really lack the ability to conduct a meaningful history and physical. At Stritch, we have Medical Spanish as an elective you can take, or as a course you can take outside of school. I believe having Medical Spanish as a required part of our curriculum would be beneficial. Given our schools commitment to international medical outreach and ISI trips, it makes sense to teach the language skills that so many of our students will need in the near future. More importantly, Medical Spanish is a skill that is often required in our community here in Chicago and all across the U.S. Indeed, its inclusion in our curriculum would serve to improve the capabilities of the class as a whole in future clinical practice at home and abroad.
Brian D'Anza, MS4
Santiago, DR
ENT in DR -- Sustainability
Wednesday, February 24, 2010
ENT in the DR
Monday, February 22, 2010
Thoughts on PeaceCorps
So I just returned from the Dominican Republic after eight days with Loyola ENT at the ILAC mission outside of Santiago. 485 patient screenings and 119 surgeries later, I am back in the United States and I've got a few things on my mind. At present, I should be reviewing material for the last half of the Step 2 medical licensing examination, but I think time would be better spent musing about a few things.
While in the DR our group needed translator assistance to help out the linguistically challenged medical staff. Towards that end we picked up seven very capable Peace Corps volunteers who took time out of their respective projects to facilitate the daily workings of our clinic. Over the course of the week we got to know the Peace Corps volunteers quite well and heard each's own story of how they came to where they are right now: in a foreign land working with people they arguably don't know on tasks for which many of them had no prior experience let along expertise. My respect for them is genuine and without equivocation.
Indeed I have met quite a few Peace Corps alumnae in my class who are very hard working, globally minded individuals, with solid senses of personal and professional direction. Sure there are a few who suspiciously seem to have learned nothing from there experience, but that could be said about people in any situation, let alone one requiring as much fortitude as Peace Corps.
Peace Corps was a pubic service initiative that was founded by an executive order from the Kennedy Administration to spread aid and foster US-foreign relations in underserved communities. Unlike its uglier domestic step-sisters (eg. Teach for America, or AmeriCorps) the Peace Corps requires a much longer time commitment. This makes it an excellent tool for undertaking long term projects if it takes advantage of developing generative projects that can, in the best case, adopted and run by communities being served or at the least handed off to the next volunteer in the area. Such projects can be as simple as a teaching computer technology skills in developing nations or as complex as managing sustainable crop growing strategies in marginally arable areas. One of the translators, an ex-swimwear model, told me a her project to develop reliable and efficient sanitation to her community. How she had worked with the community leaders to outline a way to protect the drinkable water supply by first creating a way to collect and quarantine waste, how she was furiously writing grants to obtain funding to start working through the phases of her plan, and how she planned to get the project started for the next volunteer to complete. From my own perspective, having as much difficulty actually generating waste as I have, I was just impressed at the mind-boggling layered planning. Many very capable people in the United States cannot put together projects with any foreseeable planning for subsequent phases, even with the vast resources that a well developed western society has to offer. Thus a well described (or at least well intended) plan of action from someone in the field whose prior training in waste disposal included little more than using acetone to strip fingernail polish is absolutely stunning.
The unfortunate reality of the situation is that Peace Corps has an institutionalized handicap built into its framework: no volunteer is allowed to remain in on location for more than five years. The rationale for this rule is to keep the ideas generated and implemented by the sharp end of Peace Corps (the volunteers) fresh and new. After all, one of the missions of Peace Corps is to foster American understanding of cultures abroad so that their influence on the volunteers can be translated back to America upon their return home (though returning home can be particularly difficult for the volunteers). Returning to the longevity of development projects, this renewal of personnel costs projects time and may cause them to stall out entirely if the volunteer is either not suited to the project or if the community does not grow out of the hand holding that Peace Corps is willing to offer. One of the things I respected the most about working with Habitat for Humanity was their presence of mind to be upfront about giving “a hand up” not “a hand-out”. Future owners were expected to be partners in process not just worthy/gracious recipients. This could be enforced by the long term governance of Habitat Boards, but I wonder how this could be handled in the Peace Corps without stirring up the old fires of suspicion that plagued the early volunteering efforts. In the 60s PCVs were criticized for being neo-imperialists inflicting Americanism on the locals like as though they soiled the very ground they touched. Another one of our PCVs told us that the people of her community were afraid she was a CIA spy for the majority of the first year she was in country. “What was I going to spy on,” one of her friends argued on her behalf, “ the bananas?” Regardless, America has had a number of questionable moments in its history, such that even positive programs like the Peace Corps must tread lightly, even if it means sacrificing progress for diplomacy.
Beyond the programs of the American mission abroad, what can be said about the volunteers themselves? At first glance you could make them out to be quite heroic folk: separated from thoroughly American upbringings, often following college ridiculousness, and placed into often poverty stricken areas. They're given a pittance of a salary, a nebulous job, and asked to MacGyver something out of it... if only they had the requisite swiss army knife, rubber band, and chewing gum. But what causes these graduate of higher education to sojourn into the unknown? As so many land-grant college graduates know, liberal arts educations do not gain you jobs. Education in America has turned towards acquiring technical skills to take you into the next salary bracket, which has unfortunately left the educational philosophy of “learning how to learn” to a minority of students. No longer are classical educations taught so that the strengths and weakness of the past can be examined to help shape future decisions, rather we are taught how to tabulate and compound, strategize how to operate within the rule that other men have set up, rather than examining and enhancing those rules. No. Like lemmings marching towards an unknown inevitability we scamper to get out degrees, our jobs, mates, mortgages, and some kids so that we can sit down with a six pack and watch our sitcoms or NASCAR. Is it in this light that some choose to spread their wings and take a chance with the winds of change that Peace Corps may bring? I would guess that it is something slightly less romantic where the volunteer is not sure what he or she wants to do with life yet and does not want to just plop down in the first employment opportunity that winks at them and buys them a drink a the bar. So they take a chance, hoping that biding their time doing something ostensibly positive in the ether of existence may eventually light the spark. Two years of reflection. Two years of the most contemporary liberal education available. Two years to find out how they can make their impact on society, or at the very least constructively contribute to the America that they had the unique experience of seeing from outside in. And now with Bush II, and Obama expanding the number of volunteers in a time of economic floundering there will be more opportunities for our generation to find their way to the benefit of many.
Of course, this may just be a guess and wishful thinking, but I don't know how anyone could come back from that experience and not be changed in such a way that they could be satisfied going back to the states and languish away pushing pencils to keep the American machine humming. However the return home can be equally as big of a leap as leaving the secure confines of your culture. Riding in the state rooms and on the deck of the cruise ship does not let you see all the dents, dings, barnacles and corrosion that is readily apparent from the decks of smaller vessels passing by. Life is simpler when you have less making things like right and wrong much easier to discriminate especially in a wider view like an ethos or core belief. Moving back to the land of plenty with its infinite spectrum of grays between black and white could easily be daunting enough to inspire one to look for a way out back to simpler... which may not be that bad of a thing, at the very least its a plan.
At the end of the day, the Peace Corps is an institution that is hard at work for all Americans, shaping the image of the US abroad while also structuring and strengthening its volunteers to transcend the rote for something greater. I would like to think that, given the option, I would be able to do something like this but I realize that my palsied french abilities, extreme xenophobia, combined with my generally goofy appearance means that I would probably be less than successful. However, this does not exclude me from being a swimwear model.
Thank you again to all who have supported this trip, to the ILAC mission in Santiago, and a special thanks for the tireless efforts of our Peace Corps volunteers. I wish you the best in the future.
Christopher Janowak MSIV
Santiago, Dominican Republic
Sunday, February 21, 2010
ENT DR trip - last thoughts
Some of the patients I met I know I will remember for a long time. Especially the Haitian patients we had. They had immigrated to the DR before the earthquake in search of a better life. The Haitian people, however, were treated as second class citizens in the DR and lived in shanty-towns. Their health status reflected this situation, and it was heartbreaking to see these gentle, poor people.
In conclusion, the ENT sponsored DR trip was a great experience for me. I am so thankful to have had the opportunity to attend, and I resolve to go on future trips as often as I can.
ENT DR trip - last half
The people there are tough. They showed a lot of hardiness to our exams and procedures - more so than what we are used to seeing in the States. Most kids let us do an ear exam without any fuss at all! They also all waited very patiently for their turn in the clinic. Every morning when we made our way to the clinic at 6:45 am, the place was packed with patients. But everything progressed very orderly. And no one ever complained about how long they had to wait.
As we approached the end of the week, we learned that we did not have enough medicines to give out to patients. So, we had to write down the name of the medicines and explain that they needed to go to a pharmacy to obtain them. We fashioned a home-made prescription paper for them. We also had patients come on the last day of clinic who would have really benefited from surgery, but at that time we could not fit them in! It was frustrating to have this happen. We resolved to work better with the health promoters to ensure that, in the future, these patients could get in earlier in the week.
ENT DR trip - first couple days
Fortunately, the ILAC center is a well-organized and resourceful place. The planners and administration for the trip also did a great job ensuring we had all the supplies necessary. We spent our first day unpacking and getting the OR ready for action. We also screened many patients and developed an OR schedule for the first day. We finished the day getting to know everyone better and went to bed anxious for our first big day.
On OR day 1/clinic day 2, I spent the day in clinic. I had my own room to see patients and a translator to boot! Our translators were all PeaceCorp volunteers in the DR, and they were invaluable resources for understanding language, culture, and customs. They were instrumental in the success of our trip! We saw so many patients in clinic. As soon as one was finished, the next was quickly ushered in without any delay. I performed the exam and presented to the attending, and then we set the patient up with either medical therapy or scheduled them for an operation for the week. All in all, it ran very efficiently.
The OR likewise ran efficiently. Interestingly, before each patient was led back to the operating room, all the people said a prayer and applauded the patient. I can't imagine the fear that some of the patients and families had. I know I would be fearful going into surgery by doctors who I did not know, with whom I could not personally communicate, and who I would likely never see again.
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
The World is My Classroom… 02/06/10: India
Learning the lessons of poverty around the world.
The algebraic formulas that estimate the rate of hunger;
The stories of those that fight for their right to eat.
The history of wars spawn to preserve an ideology,
Only to find out that those who led the war carried hatred and malfeasance towards humanity.
The science of illness and disease,
That ravage the bodies of the old and young alike-
And many lost to diseases and illnesses for which we have cures for.
What is captured in the stories and tales of life can not be read,
Because the authors do not know how to write-
But their words are none-the-less as powerful and moving.
Home economics stands for different grounds when there is no home,
Only a temporary place to lay your head under what would otherwise be a beautiful star-filled night.
The wear and tear on your body and joints is put to the test through this physical course,
So much so that some can not endure-
And begin to fall at your feet.
Yet with all the hardships that you bear witness to,
The joy in humanity still shines through.
Songs of hope and perseverance.
Tales of opportunity and a chance of reaching utopia.
The dream that when you reach out during a time of need,
A hand is there to greet you.
You come out leaving this classroom better than you did coming in,
But only if you happened to have an open mind and learn the lessons within.
Now you have become the student, in my classroom, in our world.
It is time for you to be the teacher.
Spread the word, teach others the lessons that you learn.
Don't let yourself be silenced when the shouts of injustice beckon.
You have a responsibility, in a position of privilege, in a position of power.
Use it.
Do something human,
Do something for humanity.
Too many people are counting on your education to mean something,
So don't let these lessons be lost.
Be the change you want to see in the world,
Be the change the world needs.
Write the new lesson plans of the future,
For I would like to continue learning, and continue exploring.
The world is my classroom…
And you are my teacher.
Ruben Frescas, MS4
India